The $5,000 Rule

Repair it, or
replace it?

Two sliders and the rule the pros use give you a straight answer in seconds. No sales pressure, no email wall.

4.9 · 515 Google reviews

Repair quote$1,200
System age10 years
-

The $5,000 rule: multiply the repair quote by the age of the system. Over $5,000 leans replace, under leans repair. It is a rule of thumb, not gospel - refrigerant type, efficiency, and how many repairs you have already paid for all matter. A free second opinion settles it.

How to Read It

The $5,000 Rule, Explained

1. The Math
Multiply the repair quote by the age of the system. A $500 repair on a 10-year unit lands at $5,000, right on the line.
2. Over $5,000
Leans replace. Old systems that need a big repair tend to break again soon, so you end up paying twice.
3. Under $5,000
Leans repair. Fix it, keep it running, and plan the replacement on your terms instead of in a July breakdown.
Fair Questions

Repair or Replace, Answered

It is a solid starting point, not a guarantee. Old R-22 systems get expensive to repair, efficiency gains can pay for a replacement, and how many repairs you have already paid for all move the answer. That is what a free second opinion is for.
Usually yes. A small repair on an old system is fine - just know the clock is running, and start planning the replacement so you are not caught in a heat wave.
No. Nobody here works on commission. We tell you to repair when repair is the right call, even when it is the smaller invoice.
Real Customers

What New Braunfels Customers Say

5.0★ · 515 Google reviews

See All Reviews on Google

Ready For Your Exact Price?

Free in-home load calculation. Written, flat-rate, no obligation.

Call (830) 587-5790